Thomas J Parlette
“A Holy Day Built on Metaphor”
John 16: 12-15
6/15/25
Last week, was Pentecost Sunday, the day we celebrate the gift of the Holy Spirit and the inheritance we receive as heirs of God, and joint-heirs with Christ.
This week, on Trinity Sunday, we continue with some more Spirit-speak as we consider the Holy Spirit’s relationship with God and Jesus. Today, we join a conversation that has been going on since the early days of the Christian community. And yet, if you do a google search on where to find the word “Trinity” in your Bible, you will come up empty. The word Trinity does not exist in our scriptures.
What you will find is a bunch of verses that mention the three persons of the Trinity, many of them in Paul’s writings – such as 2nd Corinthians 1: 21-22, 3: 17 and 13:4. You would also find references in the Gospel of John, the Gospel of Luke and the well-0known reference in Matthew 28 – Go therefore and make disciples of all nations in the name of the Father, the Son and the Holy Spirit. But the word “Trinity is not in the Bible.
So why do we place such importance on the Trinity?
Well, let me give you my 5 cent hi8story tour of how the doctrine of the Trinity came to be.
At the end of the First century, after Jesus had departed and Paul and his friends had started some churches, references began to pop up in sermons from the Early Church Fathers. Preachers such as Clement of Rome, who died in 100 AD, has a line in one of his sermons that says – “Do we not have one God, and one Christ, and one gracious Spirit that has been poured out upon us, and one calling in Christ.” All three persons of the Trinity are named.
Ignatius of Antioch, somewhere around 110 AD, encouraged obedience to “Christ and to the Father, and to the Spirit.” Again, all three persons of the Trinity are named.
And finally, Justin Martyr, who lived from 100-165 AD, once wrote what sounds like a benediction, “in the name of God, the Father and Lord of the Universe, and of our savior Jesus Christ, and of the Holy Spirit…”
So Trinitarian language has been around as part of the church’s preaching since the beginning. But the doctrine of the Trinity had not taken shape yet.
Somewhere between 168 and 183, the theologian Theophilus introduced the term “Trinity” in Greek to describe the relationship between the Father, Son and Holy Spirit. About 40 years later, in 220 AD, the theologian Tertullian introduced the word for Trinity in Latin. And since the church at the time favored Latin in the worship of the church, Tertullian usually gets most of the credit for introducing the Trinity as a concept.
After the term Trinity had been introduced, both Athanasius and Augustine had a hand in shaping it into a doctrine. It wasn’t until 325 AD, during the First Council of Nicaea, in what is now Turkey, that the doctrine of the Trinity was formalized into our Christian theology. That Council produced what is known as The Nicene Creed – we use it often during our worship services. The creed grew out of the need to more fully explain the person of Jesus as both God and human. But it also included a traditional Trinitarian concept.
Part of the Creed goes like this:
“We believe in one God, the Father Almighty, Maker of all things visible and invisible. And in one Lord Jesus Christ,
The Son of God,
Begotten of the Father,
Light of Light,
Very God of very God,
Begotten, not made,
Being of one substance with the Father.
And we believe in the Holy Ghost.”
I hope you see how heavily The Nicene Creed leans into the identity of Jesus, as well as establishing the three persons of the Trinity.
In our own day, the generally accepted Doctrine of the Trinity would be something along the lines of “There is one God in whom there are three “persons” who share one substance.” (1) This is where we have some major disagreement with our Muslim and Jewish friends, the other two religions based on Monotheism – the worship of one God. They look at our Doctrine of the Trinity and say – “Well look right there, you Christians worship three Gods, not one. You worship God, Jesus and the Holy Spirit – three gods. We worship one God.”
I can understand their point. I’m not agreeing with them, but I can understand their viewpoint – it does sound like we worship three Gods. But we don’t. The Trinity is confusing, even for those of us who have grown up in the church. To try to alleviate the confusion and explain what we mean about “God in Three persons, blessed Trinity,” we have come up with countless metaphors.
The most well-known explanation of the Trinity is as “Father, Son and Holy Spirit.” Over the years, I have also heard the Trinity described as the “God who Was, who Is and who Is to Come,”
or God “Above us, Among us and Beyond us.”
There’s also God as “Parent, Friend and Companion.”
Or, my personal favorite, God as “Creator, Redeemer and Sustainer.”
All of those metaphors are appealing in their own way, but they are all basically re-naming the Persons of the Trinity based on their relationship to each other and to us.
Another strategy to help us understand the Trinity is to focus on what “one substance” means. For instance:
An egg has three parts. The shell, the whites and the yolk – but it’s one egg.
Water – H2O – can come in three forms, a liquid, a solid – like ice, or a gas – like steam. But it’s still one substance, H2O, water.
A woman can be a wife, a mother and a business owner – but she is still one woman. (2)
A man can be a husband, a father and an employee – but he is still one man.
Or, there’s always my favorite – the Trinity is like a piece of candy corn. Candy corn is made up of three sections – white, orange and yellow. But they all taste the same, they are of one substance – waxy, corn syrup.
Poet and Theologian Maren Tirabassi took a different tack in her thinking about the Trinity when she posted the first part of a poem she wrote called “Theology for Trinity Sunday” on her Facebook page in 2023:
“God is not like a braid, not a tousled lob.
God is like a symphony, not a soloist.
God is like a family, any shape family –
Steps and blends and chosen,
water cooler family and
recovery group family…
not like a hermit.
God is like a soup kitchen
where everyone eats together,
worker and guest.
God is not like take-away.
God sounds like the United Nations
Or a really big airport,
God doesn’t sound
Like a national anthem,
Anyone’s national anthem… (3)
Rebekah Le Mon once preached a sermon called “Circle Up” on Day 1.org in which she recalled being in a theology class many years ago.
“The professor put out a challenge: to try and think of something – anything – that could serve as an adequate metaphor for a divine being that is simultaneously, eternally, three distinct and equally necessary persons.”
“The answers were earnest, but inadequate – water can exist in three states of ice, liquid and steam and retain its substance as water. Yes, but not at the same time, and ice, water and steam don’t depend on each other.”
“A stool has three legs – separate, coexisting, all necessary for the stool to stand. Yes, but they are identical parts, not distinct, and well surely, we can come up with something better than a stool.”
“Triplets!” someone said. I thought that was clever. Triplets share genetic traits, but are different persons… but they don’t have to live together in order to be whole.”
“Finally, a voice offered this image, which has become a mental picture for me of this holy and unique mystery; the Trinity is like a circle dance.”
“I pictured in my head that classic moment on playgrounds and parks when a group of kids around 8 years old form a circle and clasp hands. They promise that none of them will let go and then they all lean back just far enough that they are all supporting and being supported at the same time. And then they spin, leaning back, gripping tightly to one another, knowing that the exhilaration of this union comes from the fact that none of them could have this experience if the others weren’t there. Or, if heaven forbid, someone dropped hands. They can know the joy of this particularly freeing dance because they are all there.” (4)
The Doctrine of the Trinity, God in Three Persons - Father, Son and Holy Spirit, only holds together if all three are present, holding hands, connecting us all as we whirl and spin in the dance of life. If we lose one “person”, the dance collapses.
So when we speak of the Trinity, we speak of the three ways that God makes God-self known to us:
God, the Creator of all that is, including us, as God relates to us as a parent figure.
God, as one of us, who is intimately familiar with what it is to be human.
God as a continuing presence that walks with us in every situation we face.
Yes, that is a mystery that is difficult to wrap out heads around. We as a church have come up with many different metaphors to explain what we mean, and I’m sure that every generatio9n will add to that collection of metaphors.
But God and the Trinity will always remain a mystery. That is just something we’ll have to live with. As one of our great Trinitarian hymns puts it:
“Holy Father, Holy Son, Holy Spirit;
Three we name you, while in essence one;
Undivided God we claim you, and adoring,
Bend the knee while we own the mystery.” (5)
May God be praised. Amen.
1. Philip Turner, Feasting on the Word, Westminster John Knox Press, 2010, p 44.
2. Homileticsonline, retrieved May 20th, 2025.
3. Maren Tirabassi, “Theology for Trinity Sunday”, posted on the author’s Facebook page, 2023
4. Rebekah LeMon, “Circle Up”, June 4th, 2023, Day1.org.
5. Ignaz Franz, “Holy God, We Praise Your Name” Glory to God: The Presbyterian Hymnal, Westminster John Knox Press, 2013.